Impression titles are judged on the following criteria
Story: Characters, plot, writing style…
Artwork: The goo the bad and the ugly…
Translation: Does it read well in English? Does the translator offer notes regarding lesser known concepts? Is the teacher in me screaming bloody murder because of all of the grammatical errors?
Editing: Are the scans clean and clear? Are the re-draws noticeable? Are there typos or awkward text alignments?
Re-readability: Would I be inclined to read it again?
Each criterion can be given a score of:
These are totaled and then divided by 5 to get the mean or Final Score.